REVIEW:  Ana Maria Trenchi Bottazzi
                   Carnegie Hall
                   February 11th, 2001

In a perfect world, each of us should be our own hero.  But this isn’t a perfect world so most of us need someone to show us the way toward a courageous life without limits.  Ana Maria Trenchi Bottazzi is such a person.  From her near fatal car accident with its dire prognosis and a long, arduous and miraculous recovery through carving out a brilliant and successful life here in America, Dr. Bottazzi has triumphed again and again over seemingly insurmountable adversity.  This was her 16th Carnegie Hall recital.  

A world-class virtuoso with an impeccable technique, the concert opened with the Bach-Liszt Prelude and Fugue in a minor, BWV 543.  Not one of Liszt’s warhorse transcriptions, it was full of an elegance and shimmering lyricism that set the tone for the entire program.

The Chopin Sonata No. 3 in b minor, Op. 58 was the major work on the first half of the program.  Not as familiar as the better known second “funeral march” sonata, it is filled with light and joy stemming from a happy and fulfilled period in the composer’s life.  The brilliance and drama of the first movement, the airy quality of the second and driving Finale were projected with ease and perfection by Dr. Bottazzi.  Technique was never an issue—never a concern.  It was always the music and the dramatic lyricism that lead this artist.  There are those rare times in a performance when one can sense the entire audience seeming to hold its collective breath for fear of disturbing the mood of the moment.  Throughout the slow movement the artist’s many-layered golden sound, perfect phrasing and delicately balanced musical motion held the listeners spellbound.

The world premiere that concluded the first half of the program, Margarita Zelenaia’s “Pierrot’s Dreams”, was a rare treat.  Theatrically conceived, the states shifting between reality and dreams, disappointment and hope were perfectly suited to the artist’s kaleidoscope of sound.  The enthusiastic response of the audience was a tribute to both the composer and the artist.

The Mussorgsky “Pictures at an Exhibition” is an often-performed work.  Many gifted artists have attempted its colorful sketches but few have realized them with the occasional whimsy or elegance or brilliance that they deserve.  The Horowitz, Richter and most recently the Pletnev performances had set the standard.  Dr. Bottazzi’s contribution was clearly in their league but with her own stamp of individuality.  Not a phrase was left imperfectly sculpted; not a flicker of light nor a shadow neglected and not one moment of the massive drama of the “Baba Yaga’s Hut” or “The Great Gate of Kiev” left uncovered and laid before the audience.  A pianist with the orchestra at her fingertips, Dr. Bottazzi’s performance was responded to by a roar of approval and standing ovation by the huge crowd of listeners.  The three encores, Liadov’s “Musical Snuff- Box”, the E-minor posthumous Waltz of Chopin and the “Malambo” of Ginastera concluded one of the most memorable concert of recent seasons.

Phillip Dieckow is a concert pianist, author and founder and director of the 
Dieckow School of Music in Hoboken and Jersey City, New Jersey.

  Home